You know that game people play with fortune cookies, where you add "in bed" to whatever fortune you get?

My boyfriend and I do that whenever we go out for Chinese food, only instead of “in bed,” we say, “in the butt.” It started as a joke, something that he did to try to convince me to have anal sex with him. But we’ve kept it up, even though I now love backdoor sex as much as he does.

A few days ago, Eli went out to lunch with his coworkers, and I guess they went to a Chinese restaurant. That afternoon, I got a text from him. It was a picture of a fortune-cookie slip that read, “Soon a visitor shall delight you,” and at the end, he’d scrawled, “… in the butt.” A follow-up message came a moment later. “I think they gave me your cookie by mistake,” he wrote.

“I’m not expecting any visitors, though,” I wrote back, teasing him. “It must be someone else’s.”

“Well, that’s a shame,” he responded. “I’d hate to have gotten your hopes up for nothing. Guess I’ll have to come over later, just to be safe.”

I could think about nothing else for the rest of the afternoon. I spent the last few hours of the day fantasizing about Eli’s cock in my ass and my finger wiggling its way between his cheeks. By the time five o’clock rolled around, my pussy was drenched and my ass was eager to be filled. The hour-long commute back to my apartment was intolerable, and I had to keep my thighs squeezed together the entire way, partially to keep my juices from running down my legs and partly to keep from reaching down to finger-fuck myself.

Eli was outside my apartment building when I got home, and I practically tackled him in my rush to get inside. He laughed at my exuberance, but he let me drag him, running up the stairs to my fourth-floor walk-up. I didn’t even try to control myself as I rushed through the door, pulling Eli after me, and headed straight for the bedroom. I didn’t bother stripping, either, instead peeling off my panties and hiking up my dress to bare my pussy and ass to my boyfriend.

He reached between my legs and swiped his hand at my dripping pussy, gathering my juices on his fingers. He then rubbed the dew along his dick, getting it nice and slick, before pushing me down on the bed and moving in behind me. He rubbed more of my juices on my asshole, then spread my cheeks and slowly started to push his cock into my ass.

The feel of his cockhead pressing against my sphincter was enough to get me all riled up, and I moaned loudly as I felt him ease himself inside me. I was so eager to be fucked that my ass opened up for him right away, and he was able to slide balls-deep into me in one smooth, easy stroke. His cock filled my ass perfectly, and I felt every inch of him as he slid back out and then thrust back in again.

He moved slowly, teasing me, and I let him — for a while. But when I couldn’t handle his tentative, careful thrusts anymore, I took matters into my own hands. I waited until he was sliding inside me again and then bucked back as hard as I could, impaling my butt on his dick. He grunted in surprise, but he got the point, and he picked up speed.

Soon he was really pounding my ass as his balls slapped loudly against my cheeks. The action still wasn’t intense enough for me, and I energetically rocked back against him. I timed my thrusts with his strokes; every moment he slid into me, I lurched backward, taking him as deep as my ass would allow.

When we were moving too fast to maintain our rhythm, Eli pushed me flat down on the bed and knelt on the edge, giving himself a little more leverage and control. The position allowed him to go even deeper, and without me moving against him, he was able to go even faster and work up to a satisfyingly frantic pace.

As he fucked me, I couldn’t help thinking about all the other times he’d penetrated my ass, and I couldn’t believe that in all those times, I’d never felt anything as good as I did right then. That experience was the best sex of my life, and I couldn’t believe that something as ordinary for us as ass sex was giving me that kind of excitement. My body was vibrating with pleasure.

His dick felt incredible pumping in and out of my tight ass, and I didn’t want him to stop. I decided to help speed up my climax, and I slid a hand under myself so I could reach my clit. I lightly strummed my hot button, easing myself toward the edge of orgasm. I didn’t want to shoot off too soon, but I also couldn’t wait to feel my ass clench around Eli’s cock as I rocketed into the stratosphere.

Eli continued fucking my ass as I climaxed, which made the feeling so much more intense. My ass squeezed his dick hard, then released, then clenched again, over and over, as I shivered through my climax. I hadn’t experienced such an extreme orgasm in a while, and I had to pull my hand away from my pussy to keep myself from being overwhelmed.

I’d been climaxing for a few minutes before I finally felt Eli release inside me. His dick pulsed and throbbed, and then I felt him shoot off in my ass.

When we were finished, we slid up toward the middle of the bed and just lay there, catching our breath. Once Eli could speak, he turned his head toward me and said, “I’m famished. What do you say to Chinese takeout?”

Round two, it seemed, was only a phone call away.

Check out the Full Gallery