When I was in college, my roommate introduced me to his girlfriend Maddie and her roommate Carly, a flame-haired spitfire.

Later, when Jeff and I moved to an apartment near the girls, we all started hanging out together. One night we invited them over for pizza, beer, and a game of strip poker. After a few hands, Jeff suggested we play the way he and Maddie played with some of their other friends: The winner chooses which article of clothing the other players must discard. When a player is about to get naked, the winner’s instructions usually involve intimate acts, like making out, fondling, or masturbating.

We started the game, and once everyone was naked, I had to suck on Maddie’s breasts while Jeff watched. When Maddie won, I had to suck on Carly’s tits. Then Jeff had Carly go down on me. Next, Carly had Jeff and Maddie fuck in front of us. When I won, I had Maddie go down on me while I munched on Carly’s snatch.

Before the final hand, we all agreed that the winner’s choice should be an act that included everyone. I won, so I told Jeff to fuck Maddie again and, while Maddie sucked me off, I ate out Carly again. It was great and lasted a few glorious minutes before we all fell into a sweaty heap. Then Jeff and Maddie slipped into his bedroom, and Carly and I went into mine.

We tumbled onto the bed and started making out. Then Carly straddled me and began a slow grind against my cock. She was still extremely wet, so my erection slid between her lips like a hot knife through butter. Carly rose up and popped just the head of my erection into her tight snatch before sliding it back out. She was about to tease me again when I pushed up into her. I was completely engulfed by her hot hole when she began riding me like there was no tomorrow — which was great — but I had to get the upper hand or she’d finish me off too soon.

I pulled her down for a deep, tongue-probing kiss and fondled her hard nipples until she started to moan. Then I rolled her over and eased back into her. I took my time, letting her feel every inch of my cock. As her moans increased in intensity, I thrust deeper and harder, kissing and sucking her neck and breasts until I pushed her over the edge.

I kissed my way down to her pussy and began stroking her clit with my tongue, back and forth, up and down. Carly moaned and begged me to go faster. I pushed two fingers into her and stepped up the oral assault. She wanted me to make her come again, and I did. Suddenly her hands were holding my head close to her as her back arched and she let out a piercing scream. Then her body slowly relaxed and she sighed deeply.

Barely able to control myself, I turned Carly onto her hands and knees and entered her from behind. She was so hot and wet that it took only a few thrusts before I came, filling her up with my even hotter load.

We should have been too exhausted to continue, but we decided to take a shower together. When I started lathering her breasts, she reached for my cock and we were both ready to go again. Carly knelt down and took my cock into her mouth. The thought of filling that pretty mouth with my cream was tempting, but I just had to be inside her again. I pulled her up and grabbed her from behind, buried my dick deep inside her, and thrust as hard as she could take it. When I had her up against the shower wall, pounding away, she yelled out that she was coming. It was incredible. We were so busy coming and screaming that we didn’t realize someone had been banging on the bathroom door.

When we’d both slumped to the bottom of the shower, we finally heard the knocking. It was Jeff telling us that we were hogging the shower. He said if we wanted to keep fucking, we should go back to the bedroom. Of course, we did.